• October 2023 book box with three books and bookish goodies
  • October 2023 book box goodies: vamped up mask, anatomical heart soap, and book stickers.
  • white mug with black bat on it, different fall flavored teas, a clear glass skull cup with lid and straw, and a magical book stack candle
  • October 2023 book box books: Atonement of the Spine Cleaver, Fall of Ruin and Wrath and The Unmaking of Them
  • Signed copy of Atonement of the Spine Cleaver
  • Signed copy of The Unmaking of Them
  • Author art for The Unmaking of Them
  • Exclusive dust cover for Fall of Ruin and Wrath: Front
  • Exclusive dust cover for Fall of Ruin and Wrath: Back
  • July 2023 Book Box with three books, and bookish goodies
  • July 2023 Book Box: Bewitched, Garden of the Cursed and A Crown of Ivy and Glass. Bookish goodies include stickers, white tshirt with floral book print, and a book mark about liking dirty words.
1 12

Fantasy Bookly

The Starlit Pair – Personalized Quarterly Fantasy Romance Book Subscription

The Starlit Pair – Personalized Quarterly Fantasy Romance Book Subscription

$80.00
$80.00
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Quarterly Fantasy Romance Book Box - Subscriptions bill every 3 months and box ships 4–6 weeks after the cut-off date (the 5th of the box month). Our box months are January, April, July, and October.

We ship to 25+ countries, including the UK, Canada, Australia & more. Import fees may apply.

Subscribe and Save!

Because the best magic is the kind you choose.

The Starlit Pair is your quarterly fantasy-romance box built around choice. Each season, I personally read and handpick three incredible fantasy-romance titles, and you choose the two that speak to your soul.

It’s curated discovery without the overwhelm, the perfect balance between guided and personal. Every pick is designed to sweep you away into vivid worlds, heart-stopping tension, and happily-ever-afters worth rooting for.

What’s Included

  • 2 fantasy-romance books of your choice (selected from 3 quarterly picks)
  • Signed or book-plated copies when available
  • Curated by a real reader — not an algorithm
  • Ships & bills quarterly

Perfect For

  • Readers who love control and curation in one box
  • Busy romantasy fans seeking flexibility without missing out
  • Book lovers who trust Sarah’s taste but want to shape their own adventure

Why Readers Love It

You get the thrill of new fantasy discoveries, without the gamble. Whether you’re drawn to enemies-to-lovers tension, fated mates, or sweeping world-building, The Starlit Pair lets you choose your escape every quarter.

View full details

Let customers speak for us

from 5 reviews

Love getting this box in the mail. Always such a great selection of books, and everything feels very thoughtfully curated 💜

Charleen
The Fated Trove
Different and Unique

I loved my first box, I like that this small business is going about book box subscriptions in a new and different way. Having the option to pick your second book is so great!! I am so glad I stumbled upon this company!!!

Nicole
The Starlit Pair
I was shocked!

I found Fantasy Bookly on instagram. I already have a few subscriptions but sometimes I can't find one that I absolutely love. I can without a doubt promise you will love this subscription. I loved all the books. Even the special edition dust jacket! You won't be disappointed!

Jennifer
The Fated Trove

I adore this💖I look forward to opening a gift each day, and so far everything has been lovely.

Katie
25-Day Fantasy Bookly Advent Calendar | Includes 4 Books & Premium Surprises

Absolutely wonderful. Great choices of books. Good quality merch. Loved all of it. I do have to say the candle was def my favorite. I look forward to the next box!so exciting !

Crystal
The Moonmarked Chest